Music Video

Featured In

Credits

PERFORMING ARTISTS
Benjamin Gibbard
Benjamin Gibbard
Lead Vocals
Jason Patrick McGerr
Jason Patrick McGerr
Drums
Nicholas Harmer
Nicholas Harmer
Bass Guitar
Chris Walla
Chris Walla
Guitar
COMPOSITION & LYRICS
Benjamin Gibbard
Benjamin Gibbard
Songwriter
PRODUCTION & ENGINEERING
Mario S. Borgatta
Mario S. Borgatta
Assistant Engineer
Bob Ludwig
Bob Ludwig
Mastering Engineer
Rich Costey
Rich Costey
Mixing Engineer
Martin Cooke
Martin Cooke
Recording Engineer
Nicholas Fournier
Nicholas Fournier
Recording Engineer

Lyrics

[Verse 1]
There is whiskey in the water
And there is death upon the vine
There is fear in the eyes of your father
And there is "yours" and there is "mine"
There is a desert veiled in pavement
And there's a city of seven hills
All our debris flows to the ocean
To meet again, I hope it will
[Chorus]
How could something so fair be so cruel
When this black sun revolved around you?
[Instrumental]
There is an answer in a question
And there is hope within despair
And there is beauty in a failure
And there are depths beyond compare
There is a role of a lifetime
And there's a song yet to be sung
And there's a dumpster in the driveway
Of all the plans that came undone
[Chorus]
How could something so fair be so cruel
When this black sun revolved around you?
How could something so fair be so cruel
When this black sun revolved around you?
[Instrumental]
There is whiskey in the water
And there is death upon the vine
And there is grace within forgiveness
But it's so hard for me to find
[Chorus]
How could something so fair be so cruel
When this black sun revolved around you?
How could something so fair be so cruel
When this black sun revolved around you?
Written by: Benjamin Gibbard
instagramSharePathic_arrow_out