Listen to I'm Not That Girl by Idina Menzel

I'm Not That Girl

Idina Menzel

Musicals

21,047

Apple Music Note

OVERVIEW

LYRICS

Music Video

Idina Menzel - Live Barefoot At The Symphony - 2 I'm Not That Girl

Watch Idina Menzel - Live Barefoot At The Symphony - 2 I'm Not That Girl on YouTube

Featured In

Listen to Wicked (Original Broadway Cast Recording) by Stephen Schwartz, Idina Menzel, Kristin Chenoweth & Joel Grey

ALBUMWicked (Original Broadway Cast Recording)Stephen Schwartz, Idina Menzel, Kristin Chenoweth & Joel Grey

Listen to Musicals! featuring Stephen Schwartz, Idina Menzel, Kristin Chenoweth & Joel Grey

PLAYLISTMusicals!Apple Music Film, TV & Stage

Listen to Modern Broadway Essentials featuring Stephen Schwartz, Idina Menzel, Kristin Chenoweth & Joel Grey

PLAYLISTModern Broadway EssentialsApple Music Film, TV & Stage

Listen to Idina Menzel Essentials featuring Stephen Schwartz, Idina Menzel, Kristin Chenoweth & Joel Grey

PLAYLISTIdina Menzel EssentialsApple Music Pop

Listen to Kristin Chenoweth Essentials featuring Stephen Schwartz, Idina Menzel, Kristin Chenoweth & Joel Grey

PLAYLISTKristin Chenoweth EssentialsApple Music Pop

Listen to Film, TV & Stage in Spatial Audio featuring Stephen Schwartz, Idina Menzel, Kristin Chenoweth & Joel Grey

PLAYLISTFilm, TV & Stage in Spatial AudioApple Music Film, TV & Stage

Listen to Carpool Karaoke: Episode 5 Playlist featuring Stephen Schwartz, Idina Menzel, Kristin Chenoweth & Joel Grey

PLAYLISTCarpool Karaoke: Episode 5 PlaylistApple Music

Listen to Geneviève Leclerc: Influences featuring Stephen Schwartz, Idina Menzel, Kristin Chenoweth & Joel Grey

PLAYLISTGeneviève Leclerc: InfluencesApple Music

Similar Songs

Listen to The Wizard And I (From "Wicked" Original Broadway Cast Recording/2003) by Carole Shelley & Idina Menzel

The Wizard And I (From "Wicked" Original Broadway Cast Recording/2003)Carole Shelley & Idina Menzel

Listen to It Takes Two by Emily Blunt & James Corden

It Takes TwoEmily Blunt & James Corden

Listen to Seize the Day by Ben Fankhauser, Jeremy Jordan & Newsies Original Broadway Cast

Seize the DayBen Fankhauser, Jeremy Jordan & Newsies Original Broadway Cast

Listen to My Green Light by Jeremy Jordan, Eva Noblezada & Original Broadway Cast of The Great Gatsby - A New Musical

My Green LightJeremy Jordan, Eva Noblezada & Original Broadway Cast of The Great Gatsby - A New Musical

Listen to Heart of Stone (feat. Abby Mueller) by SIX

Heart of Stone (feat. Abby Mueller)SIX

Listen to Only Us by Laura Dreyfuss & Ben Platt

Only UsLaura Dreyfuss & Ben Platt

Listen to Nine to Five by Allison Janney, Charlie Pollock, Ensemble, Megan Hilty & Stephanie J. Block

Nine to FiveAllison Janney, Charlie Pollock, Ensemble, Megan Hilty & Stephanie J. Block

Listen to Dancing Through Life by Norbert Leo Butz, Kristin Chenoweth, Christopher Fitzgerald, Michelle Federer & Idina Menzel

Dancing Through LifeNorbert Leo Butz, Kristin Chenoweth, Christopher Fitzgerald, Michelle Federer & Idina Menzel

Listen to Home by Sophia Anne Caruso, Adam Dannheisser & Beetlejuice Original Broadway Cast Recording Ensemble

HomeSophia Anne Caruso, Adam Dannheisser & Beetlejuice Original Broadway Cast Recording Ensemble

Listen to In My Life / A Heart Full of Love by Amanda Seyfried, Eddie Redmayne & Samantha Barks

In My Life / A Heart Full of LoveAmanda Seyfried, Eddie Redmayne & Samantha Barks

Listen to No One Mourns the Wicked by Kristin Chenoweth, Sean McCourt, Cristy Candler & Jan Neuberger

No One Mourns the WickedKristin Chenoweth, Sean McCourt, Cristy Candler & Jan Neuberger

Listen to Princess Problems by Andrew Burnap & Rachel Zegler

Princess ProblemsAndrew Burnap & Rachel Zegler

Listen to Journey to the Past by Christy Altomare

Journey to the PastChristy Altomare

Listen to Without Love by Elijah Kelley, Amanda Bynes, Zac Efron, Nikki Blonsky & Motion Picture Cast of Hairspray

Without LoveElijah Kelley, Amanda Bynes, Zac Efron, Nikki Blonsky & Motion Picture Cast of Hairspray

Listen to What Baking Can Do by Jessie Mueller & Waitress Original Broadway Cast Ensemble

What Baking Can DoJessie Mueller & Waitress Original Broadway Cast Ensemble

Listen to The Place Where Lost Things Go (From "Mary Poppins Returns"/Soundtrack Version) by Emily Blunt

The Place Where Lost Things Go (From "Mary Poppins Returns"/Soundtrack Version)Emily Blunt

Listen to On the Steps of the Palace by Anna Kendrick

On the Steps of the PalaceAnna Kendrick

Listen to Turn It Off by Scott Barnhardt, Justin Bohon, Jason Michael Snow, Kevin Duda, Josh Gad, Brian Sears, Rory O'Malley, Andrew Rannells, Benjamin Schrader & Clark Johnsen

Turn It OffScott Barnhardt, Justin Bohon, Jason Michael Snow, Kevin Duda, Josh Gad, Brian Sears, Rory O'Malley, Andrew Rannells, Benjamin Schrader & Clark Johnsen

Listen to Just Around the Riverbend by Judy Kuhn

Just Around the RiverbendJudy Kuhn

Listen to Omigod You Guys by Annaleigh Ashford, Delta Nus, Dequina Moore, Laura Bell Bundy & Leslie Kritzer

Omigod You GuysAnnaleigh Ashford, Delta Nus, Dequina Moore, Laura Bell Bundy & Leslie Kritzer

Credits

PERFORMING ARTISTS

Idina Menzel

Vocals

Stephen Oremus

Conductor

Alex Lacamoire

Piano

Christian Hebel

Christian Hebel

First Violin

Andrew Barrett

Synthesizer Programming

Andy Jones

Percussion

Ann Labin

Violin

Dale Kirkland

Trombone

Daniel Miller

Cello

David Evans

Keyboards

Doug Purviance

Trombone

Gary Seligson

Drums

Greg Skaff

Guitar

Helen Campo

Flute

Jeanne LeBlanc

Cello

John Campo

Bassoon

John Moses

Clarinet

Jon Owens

Trumpet

Katherine Livolsi-Stern

Katherine Livolsi-Stern

Violin

Kelly Dent

French Horn

Kevin Roy

Viola

Konrad Adderley

Konrad Adderley

Bass Guitar

Laura Sherman

Harp

Maura Giannini

Violin

Paul Loesel

Keyboards

Ric Molina

Guitar

Ronald Carbone

Viola

Suzanne Ornstein

Suzanne Ornstein

Violin

Theo Primis

French Horn

Tom Hoyt

Trumpet

Tuck Lee

Oboe

Victor Heifets

Violin

Victor Schultz

Violin

COMPOSITION & LYRICS

Stephen Schwartz

Stephen Schwartz

Composer

Stephen Oremus

Arranger

Peter R. Miller

Peter R. Miller

Copyist

William David Brohn

William David Brohn

Orchestrator

PRODUCTION & ENGINEERING

Frank Filipetti

Frank Filipetti

Mixing Engineer

Jason Spears

Assistant Mixing Engineer

Justin Shturtz

Assistant Engineer

Stephen Schwartz

Stephen Schwartz

Producer

Jason Stasium

Mixing Engineer

Lyrics

[Verse 1]

Hands touch, eyes meet

Sudden silence, sudden heat

Hearts leap in a giddy whirl

He could be that boy

But I'm not that girl

[Verse 2]

Don't dream too far

Don't lose sight of who you are

Don't remember that rush of joy

He could be that boy

I'm not that girl

[Bridge]

Every so often, we long to steal

To the land of what-might-have-been

But that doesn't soften the ache we feel

When reality sets back in

[Verse 3]

Blithe smile, lithe limb

She who's winsome, she wins him

Gold hair with a gentle curl

That's the girl he chose

And Heaven knows I'm not that girl

[Outro]

Don't wish, don't start

Wishing only wounds the heart

I wasn't born for the rose and the pearl

There's a girl I know

He loves her so

I'm not that girl

Written by: Stephen Schwartz

Shazam Footer

Select language:

Company

Legal

Chrome Web Store

Galaxy Store

Follow Us

© Copyright 2025 Apple Inc. and its affiliates | Supplier Responsibility